I always give my friends theirb stuff back if I pk the guy who killed them.....but like if it was 9 mill and it wasa friends friend...nto a friend. It'd be a debate between the angel on one shoulder and the devil on the other......
Saradomin and Zamorak are on your shoulders.
Sara: "Give it back to him, for the peace and tranquility of RuneScape." Zammy: "What, are you nuts? Keep it and buy all the dragon weapons that I introduced to RuneScape!"
I don't give away free stuff often. It's too risky. If you come to be known for giving away stuff then the word will spread and you'll have 50,000 people asking for free things. I don't need noobs begging any more than they do now.