Now, yesterday, i was fishing lobbs, and GOD!!! IT IS SLOW!!!!
so i went and got a calculator, and looked at it, it said trouts give 50 xp, salmon gives 70 xp and lobbies give 90xp
i'm like : "Argh!"
So i go fly fishing, and damit, i get fish 5x as fast as lobbies and 2-3X the xp!!!
Now I'm at barb village fly fishing and dropping, waaaaaay better xp than lobbies, the lesson here is NEVER go fishing something unless you have 2X the level required
PS: I'm still sad at the 2 days i spent fishing lobbies, i wished i found out sooner

I had 12k river fish in my bank, which I gave away JUST BEFORE they introduced cook-x :'(...
And yes shilo is the quickest fly fishing available